The Plastic Saxophone

A com­pany based in Thai­land has made a plas­tic sax­o­phone, called the Vibrato. had a chance to test out a Vibrato model A1S and take a look at the mechan­ics from a sax­o­phone repairman’s point of view.

(Click on any photo for a high res­o­lu­tion version)

In the way­back times, an Eng­lish com­pany made an acrylic sax­o­phone aimed at pro­fes­sion­als called the Grafton . They are frag­ile, rare, and dif­fi­cult– but pos­si­ble– to repair. But when you find one in good shape, they play very well. Char­lie Parker famously played a Grafton for a while.

The Vibrato is a dif­fer­ent beast alto­gether. Accord­ing to the com­pany, the aim of the project was to make an afford­able stu­dent sax­o­phone, and the deci­sion was made to make it out of plas­tic to achieve that end.

 

As a bit of back­ground, I have some expe­ri­ence in the field of stu­dent sax­o­phone design, hav­ing gone so far as a sax­o­phone fac­tory in Viet­nam to con­sult and improve their prod­uct. I am my cur­rent employer’s main con­tact when it comes to improv­ing their stu­dent sax­o­phone prod­uct line– a process I have the increas­ingly enjoy­able task of wit­ness­ing first­hand as our num­ber of war­ran­teed repairs drop as the sax­o­phones increase in qual­ity. There­fore my eye is trained not only towards the imme­di­ate expe­ri­ence of see­ing the horn (which again is waaaay cool) but also think­ing about how it would hold up under years of heavy use.

The two types of springs on the horn- coiled (to replace flat springs) and U-bent needle springs. The springs were very squishy-feeling, or as I like to say, "analog". I aim for what I call a digital feel in my work as a repairman.

The idea of years of use in par­tic­u­lar is an area where theA1S has some major draw­backs. For instance, with a tra­di­tion­ally built sax­o­phone, there are ways to adjust the rela­tion­ships between the keys so that they act how they should– what we in the repair busi­ness cre­atively call the adjust­ments. These adjust­ments are nec­es­sary because we have 10 fin­gers and are actu­at­ing 23 or so keys on a sax­o­phone– there­fore cer­tain keys must act together at cer­tain times, and they must seal per­fectly air­tight with min­i­mal pres­sure and at exactly the same time. Due to vari­a­tions in man­u­fac­ture, thick­ness of pads installed and other fac­tors, these adjust­ments must be made indi­vid­ual to each horn by a qual­i­fied repair­man as the horn is put into play­ing shape. With­out proper adjust­ments, a horn sim­ply won’t play. Inter­est­ingly, this con­cept is also illu­mi­nated with the short­com­ings of the 3D-printed flute I posted/ranted about a lit­tle while back.

On the Vibrato A1S, there are cer­tain areas where it seemed there are no read­ily avail­able ways to adjust the sax­o­phone in the tra­di­tional sense! And being built of plas­tic, even bend­ing the keys into the cor­rect adjust­ment is not an option. So if the horn comes out of the fac­tory out of adjust­ment or is dam­aged some­how, your options could be very lim­ited depend­ing on where the prob­lem is– in my case it was the A/bis rela­tion­ship, which was out of whack and kept me from being able to play the horn. On a sax­o­phone made of plas­tic, every pos­si­ble adjust­ment must have a way to, er, be adjusted.

Per­haps if I had more time with the instru­ment, I may have fig­ured it out, but with­out dis­as­sem­bly it was not imme­di­ately appar­ent how to fix the prob­lem– a prob­lem that would have been a very sim­ple fix on a tra­di­tion­ally designed saxophone.

Even assum­ing that the adjust­ing meth­ods are improved upon, a sec­ond prob­lem presents itself: with­out key­work stiff enough to trans­fer the player’s energy with­out bend­ing, the horn won’t play even if the adjust­ments are cor­rect. I found the key­work on the A1S to be very flex­i­ble. In the video at the bot­tom of this post, you can see sev­eral instances where the key­work is bend­ing quite a bit under light pressure.

Per­haps these con­cerns are some­thing the com­pany will address in the future– I know that although they are sell­ing the Vibrato as of now, they are actively engaged in improv­ing the design.

Another inter­est­ing design fea­ture is that the horn body tube is assem­bled from many sec­tions, and each sec­tion is rein­forced with a thicker por­tion where the sec­tions meet. The exte­rior of the body tube is smooth, but the inte­rior reduces at each of these rein­forced sec­tions to make room for the extra bulk. Per­haps they have made acoustic allowances for this (again, the horn was in a mostly unplayable state so I was unable to test into­na­tion), but it flies in the face of acoustic design. The inte­rior dimen­sions of the bore are what give the horn its into­na­tion– or lack thereof– and as far as I know this is the only sax­o­phone ever made with dra­matic reduc­tions in the bore at cer­tain areas. This phe­nom­e­non is most eas­ily viewed in the video at the bot­tom of this post.

While the horn was in my pos­ses­sion, I was able to shoot a few pho­tos and a quick hands-on video. I apol­o­gize for the qual­ity of the shoot­ing– I held the cam­era while try­ing to film and also had no time to prac­tice what I was going to say. I left it unedited. The video is below, and is view­able in full 1080p on youtube.

The Vibrato A1S sax­o­phone, while oper­a­ble in its most opti­mal state, seems frag­ile, and hon­estly feels pretty awful under the fin­gers because of spring design, the flex­i­bil­ity of the plas­tic, and the gimbal-mounted pads that work their way sealed incre­men­tally as you press down. My expe­ri­ence was also poor due to the fact that the par­tic­u­lar horn I had access to had either ship­ping dam­age or a flaw in its man­u­fac­ture that I did not know how to prop­erly cor­rect (which again would have been an easy fix on a tra­di­tion­ally designed sax). So far, the pric­ing for these instru­ments is in the $400 range, for which price you can eas­ily buy a used Yamaha YAS-23 or any one of sev­eral accept­able new import stu­dent saxophones.

Accord­ing to my expe­ri­ence so far, while what Vibrato has done is excep­tion­ally cool and wor­thy of admi­ra­tion for the sheer inven­tive­ness of their efforts, they also have excep­tion­ally far to go to defeat the sta­tus quo.

 

 

 

————–UPDATE————

After pub­lish­ing my quickie repairman’s review, I received a nice email from the pres­i­dent of Vibrato, Piya­pat Thanyak­ijj. I have received his per­mis­sion to pub­lish it here:

Hi
I’m enjoyed watch­ing your video on A1S. Thank you for all your rec­om­mended improve­ment. How­ever on your video you’ve men­tioned that the A key and the arm with pad are split­ting that was wrong, they are on the same rod. If you found the plays , it’s mean that the key or the arm was lose from the hex-rod ( one of them ). You can glue it back on by using Meth­yl­ene Chlo­ride just a tiny drop on the join between Rod & Key.

We have checked all of the sam­ple short for each batch and found out that some batch have uneven tone hole sur­face on A due to injec­tion con­di­tion. If you still found the leaks after glu­ing please file the tone hole just to make sure it flat & even ( we’re now doing it before assemble ).

We are now suc­ceeded with replace all nee­dle springs with coil spring. It gives us some advan­tage over nee­dle spring for exam­ple elim­i­nate all ten­sion on plas­tic post , solve the prob­lem of attach­ing the nee­dle spring on plas­tic post, the player can now be able to choose their own ten­sion of spring pres­sure since we will make it in 2 or 3 dif­fer­ent ten­sion available,improve the action speed.

We also have beef up sev­eral keys on lower stack and make it more rigid . The flex you’ve found is most likely cost by when the pad was seated while there are some room for the key to move by our fin­ger so we add a stop­per to all those keys which we believed it will gives more rigidFEEL when played.

And a sec­ond email:

You can pub­lish on your blog as you wanted. This might be our final mod­i­fi­ca­tion on A1 because I have to start design­ing T1 soon all the issue from A1 will be addressed I think we will make it right on Tenor if we suc­ceeded those idea will be trans­fer back to A1 but it will call A2 this time.“

He also sent a few pho­tos of body and key­work mod­i­fi­ca­tions, some of which I have posted here.

It’s not every day the pres­i­dent of a com­pany takes the time to address youtube videos and reviews writ­ten by Joe Repair­man out in the field. Here’s to Vibrato for being open, inter­ested, and moti­vated to improve their prod­uct. I look for­ward to see­ing the A2!

 

 



RARE Keilwerth New King Series II Alto Saxophone
1951 Martin “The Martin” Committee III Tenor Saxophone, All Original
Selmer Super Sax “Cigar Cutter” Alto Saxophone, Gold Plate
How to Choose a Saxophone Mouthpiece