Why Cheap Saxophones Are Cheap


Curt Altarac, a fel­low sax­o­phone repair spe­cial­ist here in North Car­olina put together a great arti­cle at MusicMedic.com based on the expe­ri­ence of one of his appren­tices fit­ting the keys (aka rebuild­ing the mechan­ics) of a cheap East Asian import sax.

Any of you who are repair­men read­ing this are imme­di­ately get­ting clammy, and per­haps get­ting cramps in your hands just think­ing about it. And if a for­mer appren­tice of mine is read­ing this– see? I’m not cruel and unusual. Just cruel.

Some­how this arti­cle slipped under my radar, but for those of you who are mechan­i­cally minded it is a great answer to “what is the dif­fer­ence between a $400 sax­o­phone and a $4000 saxophone?”.


In a word, craftsmanship.

One of the things you’ll notice read­ing Curt’s arti­cle  is that its really a lot of lit­tle things adding up to make the job of per­fect­ing the key­work much more inten­sive and time con­sum­ing than it nor­mally would be.

Its get­ting things right that takes time, and there­fore money. Get­ting things to 80 or 90 per­cent right can be done in less than 80 or 90 per­cent of the time it takes to get things 100 per­cent right. Just like when you prac­tice a piece of music, its the last few per­cent on the way to per­fec­tion that take up most of your time. Like a log­a­rith­mic curve approach­ing the Y-axis or a massed par­ti­cle approach­ing light­speed, you can approach per­fec­tion– but never meet it. The closer you get to per­fec­tion the more energy it takes.

I do believe that the cheap imported sax­o­phones play a very valu­able role– the role of being a 3–4 year horn that gets you started on the cheap. One that if you treat it right will last you just about until you start to notice its shortcomings.

Per­haps my expe­ri­ence vis­it­ing a fac­tory in Viet­nam plays a part in this, but I also believe that these instru­ments play an impor­tant part in bring­ing up stan­dards of liv­ing in the locales where they are man­u­fac­tured. What is appar­ently unprof­itable and unwanted work here in the US is con­sid­ered mod­er­ately skilled labor else­where, allow­ing folks to earn a decent liv­ing and adding choice to their lives.



Black Pearls on Wartime SML Coleman Hawkins Special Tenor
Martin Committee III (aka “The Martin”) Tenor Saxophone
Holton 232 Alto Saxophone (sleeper handmade in USA pro horn!)
Otto Link Mouthpieces, Past and Present